Where to Find the Best Pizza in Omaha

Pizza is one of those universally loved foods, and whether you’re in Omaha for business, the Henry Doorly Zoo, or the College World Series, there’s a good chance you’ll find yourself craving a slice or two. While the city may not have the pizza fame of New York or Chicago, there are plenty of great Omaha pizza places worth checking out during your visit!

• Backlot Taphouse
• La Casa Pizzaria
• Dante
• Dolomiti
• Izzy’s Pizza
• Lyle’s Pizzeria
• Noli’s Pizzeria
• Via Farina
• Very Important Pizza
• Virtuoso Pizzeria
• Williamsburg Pizza

Backlot Taphouse

Backlot Taphouse is all about Detroit-style pizza. But there’s much more than pizza at this Aksarben restaurant, which is one of the best Omaha sports bars. Backlot has 29 taps, many of which highlight local breweries like Site-1 Brewing, Kinkaider Brewing Company, and Infusion Brewing Co. There are imported and national beers as well—plus an entire fridge full of bottles and cans. And with TVs on every wall, you won’t miss any your game’s action.

• Perfect For: Detroit-style deep dish squares, crispy-edge pan pizza, casual vibe, sharing with friends
• Yelp Rating: 4.4/5 stars out of 160+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.5/5 stars out of 500+ reviews
• Address: 2110 S 67th St Suite 108, Omaha, NE 68106
• Parking: Street parking or Aksarben Parking Garage Zone 5
• Cost: $$

La Casa Pizzaria

An Omaha staple since 1953, La Casa Pizzaria is a local favorite, but out-of-town visitors rave about it as well. With locations in Midtown, South Central Omaha, and West Omaha, La Casa’s pizza dough is flaky and buttery—almost like a thin biscuit—and every last inch of the pie is loaded with toppings. La Casa is famous for its Classic Hamburger Pizza, which has so much of their well-seasoned beef that it practically becomes its own layer.

• Perfect For: No-frills classic, thin bakery style rectangular pizza, traditional and nostalgic vibe for families
• Yelp Rating: 3.4/5 stars out of 200+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.4/5 stars out of 1,300+ reviews
• Address: 4432 Leavenworth St, Omaha, NE 68105
• Parking: Parking lot
• Cost: $

Dante

If you’re looking for authentic Neapolitan pizza, Dante is your answer. Offering some of the best pizza in West Omaha, Dante stretches each pizza by hand, tops it with farm-fresh ingredients, and cooks it in brilliant 800-degree ovens, producing gorgeous pizzas with tender insides and puffy exteriors. In addition to pizza, Dante also has an extensive wine program and a host of great pastas and wood-fired proteins to choose from.

• Perfect For: Wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas, upscale vibe for date night or fancy dinner
• Yelp Rating: 3.9/5 stars out of 300+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.4/5 stars out of 700 reviews
• Address: 16901 Wright Plaza #173, Omaha, NE 68130
• Parking: Parking lot
• Cost: $$$

Dolomiti

If you want a delicious pizza, a sandwich that uses Dolomiti’s pizza dough as bread, or a couple of appetizers to share—all of which can be enjoyed from their gorgeous outdoor patio—this hot spot just north of downtown earns its place among the best restaurants in Omaha. Located within walking distance of Charles Schwab Field, there’s also no Omaha pizza restaurant more convenient spot for College World Series visitors.

• Perfect For: Sourdough pizza, upscale vibe
• Yelp Rating: 4.6/5 stars out of 120+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.8/5 stars out of 300+ reviews
• Address: 1105 N 13th St, Omaha, NE 68102
• Parking: Street parking
• Cost: $$$

Izzy’s Pizza

Detroit-style pizza is having a moment, and if you’re curious why, just dig into a slice at Izzy’s Pizza. With a thick, fluffy dough and an outer lacing of crispy caramelized cheese, Izzy’s enormous pizzas have gained a legendary status in Omaha. You can visit the Downtown Omaha location, or follow them on social media to see where their food truck—a converted school bus aptly named “Izzy’s Pizza Bus”—will be parking next.

• Perfect For: Massive pies with crispy edges for sharing with large parties
• Yelp Rating: 4.7/5 stars out of 100+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.8/5 stars out of 180+ reviews
• Address: 522 S 24th St, Omaha, NE 68131
• Parking: Shared parking lot and street parking
• Cost: $$

Lyle’s Pizzeria

Lyle’s Pizzeria employs a sourdough crust, which ensures each pizza is light and very digestible. Located in Midtown Omaha, this Dundee pizza place is highly rated. But before you leave, make sure you get a Mozzarella & Pesto Roll—this mountain of carbs is one of the best appetizers in Omaha.

• Perfect For: Hand-stretched sourdough crust, inventive toppings, stylish interior
• Yelp Rating: 4.5/5 stars out of 100+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.6/5 stars out of 200+ reviews
• Address: 5213 Leavenworth St, Omaha, NE 68106
• Parking: Parking lot
• Cost: $$

Noli’s Pizzeria

The highlight at Noli’s Pizzeria is their New York-style pizza—the owner is so obsessed with getting it just right that he even invested in a machine to replicate the pH levels of New York water, which legend says is what makes the pizza there special. But this Blackstone pizza restaurant also serves fluffy pan-style Grandma pizzas, making it a versatile spot for those eager to try all kinds of pizza. Noli’s also has a second location in Aksarben.

• Perfect For: Classics with character, quick lunch spot
• Yelp Rating: 4.1/5 stars from 400+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.4/5 stars from 1200+ reviews
• Address: 4001 Farnam St, Omaha, NE 68131
• Parking: Street parking or Park Omaha Blackstone Garage
• Cost: $$

Via Farina

While Via Farina also has a dedicated pasta program, it’s the pizza that’s made this Downtown Omaha pizza place so popular. The dough requires three days to rest before it goes into the fiery belly of Via Farina’s brilliant orange pizza oven, emerging with a crispy bottom and soft-as-a-pillow outer edge. Via Farina has a downtown location in Little Italy, but it also has a location in West Omaha.

• Perfect For: Modern Italian lovers, stylish atmosphere, good for date nights and groups
• Yelp Rating: 4.2/5 stars out of 500+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.4/5 stars out of 700+ reviews
• Address: 1108 S 10th St, Omaha, NE 68108
• Parking: Street parking
• Cost: $$$

Very Important Pizza

A post shared by @instagram

Good luck finding crispier pizza in Omaha than the gigantic New York-style slices at Very Important Pizza. Each bite from this Omaha pizza shop elicits a satisfying crunch, and you can either order whole pies or grab pizza by the slice. Plus, once you’re done with your meal, you can indulge your inner kid and play one of the retro pinball machines. 

• Perfect For: Casual Lunch Outings 
• Yelp Rating: 4/5 stars out of 1+reviews  
• Google Rating: 4.8/5 stars out of 50+ reviews  
• Flagship Address:  2502 Farnam St, Omaha, NE 68131 
• Parking: Attached Parking Lot  
• Cost: $ 

Virtuoso Pizzeria

No one in Omaha does New York-style pizza like Virtuoso Pizzeria. One of many Benson restaurants, you can purchase whole pies or get pizza by the slice through the restaurant’s grab-and-go window. The slices are thin and large enough to get that classic New York fold, giving you a nice crispiness in each bite. Pro tip: get the Hot Honey Pizza, which is loaded with two styles of pepperoni before it’s drizzled with hot honey. It’s one of the best pizzas in Omaha.

• Perfect For: Pizza by the slice, casual sit-down vibe
• Yelp Rating: 4.1/5 stars out of 170+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.5/5 stars out of 700 reviews
• Address: 6056 Maple St, Omaha, NE 68104
• Parking: Street parking
• Cost: $$

Williamsburg Pizza

Created by legendary pizzaiolo Nino Coniglio, Williamsburg Pizza started in New York City and opened its Omaha location in 2023. It’s famous for its Brooklyn Round Crust pizzas, which have a crust that’s crispy and firm but still pliable enough to fold. This Millard pizza place also offers Grandma Square Crusts—thicker pies with a crispy, buttery bottom. Whichever style you choose, you’re in for an authentic New York pizza experience.

• Perfect For: Authentic slices, thin crust pizza, casual and fast service
• Yelp Rating: 4.2/5 stars out of 70+ reviews
• Google Rating: 4.6/5 stars out of 300+ reviews
• Address: 16869 Audrey St. Omaha, NE 68136
• Parking: Parking lot
• Cost: $$

 

Great Food Truck Options

Terrible Geralds

A post shared by @instagram

A food truck bringing an unorthodox spin on Neapolitan pizza to Omaha, Terrible Gerald’s Pizza Mobile has earned a cult following with its wood-fired pies and rotating event locations. Their dough undergoes a 48-hour fermentation process, resulting in a pillowy, leopard-spotted crust that’s hard to forget. While they keep things approachable with traditional pies, they’re best known for the Crabby Gerald—a Crab Rangoon pizza that’s become an Omaha original.

• Perfect For: Adventurous eaters, food truck fans, unique Neapolitan-style pizza with a creative twist
• Google Rating: 5/5 stars out of 66 reviews
• Location: Mobile — check their schedule for weekly event locations
• Parking: Varies by event
• Cost: $$

Johnny Riggo’s Brooklyn Pizza

A mobile pizzeria bringing Brooklyn-style pizza straight to your event, Johnny Ricco’s Brooklyn Pizza is available for private events, holiday parties, neighborhood gatherings, and company lunches and dinners. Their menu keeps things classic with a solid lineup of pies from a simple Cheese to the loaded DA MEAT with pepperoni, beef, sausage, and bacon! Standouts like the Ricco’s Red with basil pesto drizzle and caramelized red onion show they’re not afraid to get creative.

• Perfect For: Private events, parties, corporate lunches, NY-style pizza lovers
• Location: Mobile — available for booking across the Omaha area
• Parking: Varies by event
• Cost: $$

For a complete breakdown of every Omaha pizza spot on the list, watch the full video below!

A post shared by @instagram

Grabbing a slice is always a good idea—but there’s more to Omaha’s food scene worth digging into:

• Best Breakfast Spots in Omaha
• Best Brunch Spots in Omaha
• Best Burgers in Omaha
• Best Ice Cream Shops in Omaha
• Best Sports Bars in Omaha
• Best Steakhouses in Omaha
• Best Wings in Omaha
• Best BBQ in Omaha

Looking for more places to eat in Omaha? Don’t miss our other Omaha restaurant guides from Hurrdat ONE!